[bala · home]
[okadenamatī · reviews]
[mesaramatiziye · other writings]
[tedbezī · languages]
language: English
country: USA
year: 1981
form: novel
genre(s): science fiction
dates read: 13.8.26-23.8.26
C.J. Cherryh’s Downbelow Station is, as I understand it, one of the flagship novels of her Alliance–Union universe — not the first published, nor the only award-winner, but a hub around which the setting orbits.
the novel follows a large cast of characters, centering on the inhabitants of Pell Station (the titular station, typically just called “Pell”) and of Pell’s World (the titular “Downbelow”), over the course of approximately eight months during the period of the “Company War”, the armed conflict between the fleet commissioned by the Sol Company, operating out of Earth, and the independent Union, composed of outlying worlds and colonies seeking economic independence from Earth. Pell and Downbelow find themselves at the convergence of forces: a change of government and policy on Earth, a radical plan by the independently-operating “Company” fleet of Conrad Mazian, and Union’s project of political and military expansion.
there are a few main strands of this plot: through Signy Mallory, the iron-fisted and — it transpires — sexually exploitative captain of the Norway, we see the internal politics and culture of the Mazianni fleet; through the ambitious Pell politician Jon Lukas and the Sol Company representative Segust Ayres, we see Union political machinations; through Damon Konstantin, a son of Pell’s stationmaster, and Josh Talley, a former Union soldier who has been “Adjusted” (i.e., partly mindwiped) and befriended by Damon, we see the unsettling of life on Pell; through Damon’s brother Emilio and his wife Miliko we see life on the surface of Downbelow alongside its indigenous species, the hisa; through Damon’s wife Elene Quen, a former “merchanter” whose family’s ship has been destroyed by Union, we see merchanter politics and the possibility of a new political order; through the hisa Satin (aka the Storyteller, aka Tam-utsa-pitan) we get tantalizing glimpses of hisa perspectives on all of this.
this is a lot to balance! in some ways I think the novel does very well: as in the Chanur books, Cherryh here is closely attentive to the textures of her characters’ everyday lives in this space future and to shifting and clashing cultural norms and attitudes. as evidenced also in The Pride of Chanur I think Cherryh is perhaps at her best writing the tension of an immediate crisis, and I particularly appreciate her grasp of the timescales involved in intersteller travel and communication, though because the bulk of the novel is set within the Pell system there’s less of this than in the Chanur books. the plot overall is a gripping balance of tension and moments of relative ease, though with a slow start simply because of its scope. while it took some time to get adjusted to all the characters, the humans, at least, are vividly drawn and believably flawed in their own ways.
I have two main complaints. the first, as signaled by the last sentence, is that the hisa feel, basically, like an afterthought. after my prior experience with Cherryh’s sci-fi (the Chanur books are in fact set on the fringes of the Alliance–Union universe), I was looking forward to more interspecies interaction and to the development of hisa culture. ultimately, though, I think you could cut all of the Downbelow sections of the novel and all of Satin’s sections on the station without actually affecting the overall plot. while parts of the hisa thread on the station were emotionally affecting, they contributed almost nothing to the overall narrative — from start to finish the hisa felt like an out-of-place afterthought. this was a severe bummer! I can imagine an alternate version of the novel where the hisa are central to its narrative, but as it is, when at the end of the novel they are reconceiving the political future of Pell — and so, by extension, of Downbelow — nobody seems to have bothered to ask the hisa for their opinion on any of it. for a book whose human characters pay lip-service to the idea that humans shouldn’t take the hisa for granted, the novel unfortunately takes the hisa pretty well for granted.
(the question of colonialism is basically not engaged with at all — Emilio and Miliko are briefly concerned that either the Mazianni or Union will turn to Downbelow as a site of resource extraction without regard for the hisa, but Pell is already using Downbelow as a site of resource extraction and using the hisa as unpaid, if not precisely unfree, laborers. this situation is just not something the novel is interested in.)
the second is a more general problem: even when the political future of Pell is finally being reconceived, it’s never actually meaningfully clear what anyone in any of this actually wants, aside from Lukas (who just wants personal political power). there is a somewhat vague notion of “independence” for Union and/or Pell. Union is figured as an early-’80s anticommunist bogeyman in a rather indistinct way, with brainwashed subversive agents threatening to Destroy Society From Within. but at the end of the day it really seems like the only question at stake here is where the center of power will end up. this was a bit frustrating — again I’m comparing it to the Chanur novels, where the political economy was still a bit vague (generic space capitalism) but where there was at least a clear, genuine social and political transformation on the horizon from as early as The Pride of Chanur, coming to a head in Chanur’s Homecoming and Chanur’s Legacy. the end of the series has genuinely transformed Compact space in a way that has implications, direct or indirect, for everyone living in it. the end of Downbelow Station, in contrast, feels more like it’s just rearranged some furniture. considering the length of this book, I had looked forward to more.
all of that said: I enjoyed this book! now that I’ve gotten this behemoth out of the way I’m looking forward to reading more of the Alliance–Union books — eventually I will probably even tackle Cyteen. while the hisa feel disconnected from the overall narrative the parts from Satin’s perspective are at times genuinely moving — honestly I wish the whole novel had been focused on her and the other hisa, because while humans seem like they’re just rearranging furniture the hisa seem like they are on the edge of a much larger transformation. perhaps I’ll get to see more in later, or at least other, books. (I do think any of the Chanur novels would have been a more deserving Hugo winner than this, though; also honestly the Morgaine books.)
moods: adventurous, dark, hopeful, tense